Games like Storyteller on Xbox
Closest overall match: Return to Monkey Island (★ 4.0). Highest rated: Pentiment at ★ 4.3. Quickest to finish: Evan's Remains at about 2 hours.
We compared Storyteller against every game in our catalog on shared tags, genre, rating, playtime and release era, and these 8 came closest. What ties them together most: Interactive Fiction, Choose Your Own Adventure and Hand-drawn.
-
52%
1. Return to Monkey Island
Shares Cartoony, Hand-drawn, Choices Matter, Point & Click and 2D and 4 more tags; released within 1 year.
- Year
- 2022
- Rating
- ★ 4.0
- Playtime
- 3h
- Finish rate
- 76%
- Shared genres
- 3, 7
-
51%
2. Stray Gods: The Roleplaying Musical
Shares Романтика, Romance, Interactive Fiction, Choose Your Own Adventure and Hand-drawn and 5 more tags; same release year.
- Year
- 2023
- Rating
- ★ 3.9
- Playtime
- 4h
- Finish rate
- 81%
- Shared genres
- 3
-
49%
3. Escape Academy
Shares Cartoony, Visual Novel, Mystery, Steam Cloud and Steam Achievements and 1 more tags; released within 1 year.
- Year
- 2022
- Rating
- ★ 4.0
- Playtime
- 4h
- Finish rate
- 75%
- Shared genres
- 3, 7
-
49%
4. Disney Dreamlight Valley
Shares Choose Your Own Adventure and Singleplayer; rated 0.5 lower; about 5h longer; same release year.
- Year
- 2023
- Rating
- ★ 3.4
- Playtime
- 8h
- Finish rate
- 19%
- Shared genres
- 3, 14
-
47%
5. Immortality
Shares LGBTQ+, Interactive Fiction, Choose Your Own Adventure, Visual Novel and Point & Click and 4 more tags; rated 0.3 higher; released within 1 year.
- Year
- 2022
- Rating
- ★ 4.2
- Playtime
- 6h
- Finish rate
- 72%
- Shared genres
- 3, 14
-
47%
6. Evan's Remains
Shares Visual Novel, Mystery, 2D, Full controller support and Singleplayer; rated 0.4 lower.
- Year
- 2020
- Rating
- ★ 3.5
- Playtime
- 2h
- Finish rate
- 83%
- Shared genres
- 3, 7
-
47%
7. Pentiment
Shares Interactive Fiction, Choose Your Own Adventure, Hand-drawn, Multiple Endings and Choices Matter and 5 more tags; rated 0.3 higher; released within 1 year.
- Year
- 2022
- Rating
- ★ 4.3
- Playtime
- 2h
- Finish rate
- 75%
- Shared genres
- 3
-
47%
8. South of the Circle
Shares Романтика, Romance, Interactive Fiction, Point & Click and Full controller support and 2 more tags.
- Year
- 2020
- Rating
- ★ 3.7
- Metacritic
- 76
- Playtime
- 2h
- Finish rate
- 76%
- Shared genres
- 3
If you're here, you'll probably want these too
Other ways people search for this
They all land here or on the matching platform / free / co-op tab — one ranked answer, not ten thin pages.
Questions people ask
What is the best game like Storyteller on Xbox?
On our similarity model, Return to Monkey Island is the closest match to Storyteller on Xbox — shares Cartoony, Hand-drawn, Choices Matter, Point & Click and 2D and 4 more tags; released within 1 year.
Which game like Storyteller is rated highest?
Pentiment holds the highest player rating in this list at 4.3/5 from 135 players.
How this list is built
Every game in our catalog is scored against Storyteller on five signals: weighted tag overlap (rare tags count more), genre overlap, platform family overlap, rating and playtime proximity, and release era. The list is recomputed nightly as ratings and new releases change.
Base game data via RAWG.