Games like Silent Hill 2 on Xbox
Closest overall match: The Callisto Protocol (★ 3.5). Highest rated: Judgment (2019) at ★ 4.4. Newest: Mafia: The Old Country (2025). Quickest to finish: Silent Hill Homecoming at about 1 hours.
These 20 games score highest on our similarity model for Silent Hill 2 — weighted by shared tags, genre overlap, rating proximity and release era. The strongest common threads are Singleplayer, Third Person and Cinematic.
-
62%
1. The Callisto Protocol
Shares Cinematic, Survival Horror, Violent, Third Person and Singleplayer; rated 0.9 lower; about 6h longer; released within 2 years.
- Year
- 2022
- Rating
- ★ 3.5
- Metacritic
- 69
- Playtime
- 7h
- Finish rate
- 83%
- Shared genres
- 3, 4
-
60%
2. The Dark Pictures Anthology: The Devil In Me
Shares Psychological, Cinematic, Multiple Endings, Violent and Third Person and 1 more tags; rated 1.2 lower; about 5h longer; released within 2 years.
- Year
- 2022
- Rating
- ★ 3.3
- Playtime
- 6h
- Finish rate
- 93%
- Shared genres
- 3, 4
-
60%
3. Somerville
Shares Cinematic and Singleplayer; rated 1.1 lower; released within 2 years.
- Year
- 2022
- Rating
- ★ 3.3
- Metacritic
- 70
- Playtime
- 4h
- Finish rate
- 71%
- Shared genres
- 3, 4
-
59%
4. Hi-Fi Rush
Shares Great Soundtrack and Singleplayer; released within 1 year.
- Year
- 2023
- Rating
- ★ 4.3
- Playtime
- 4h
- Finish rate
- 67%
- Shared genres
- 3, 4
-
59%
5. Shadow of the Tomb Raider
Shares Violent, Exploration, Third Person, Great Soundtrack and Singleplayer; rated 0.5 lower; about 9h longer.
- Year
- 2018
- Rating
- ★ 3.9
- Metacritic
- 78
- Playtime
- 10h
- Finish rate
- 84%
- Shared genres
- 3, 4
-
59%
6. RoboCop: Rogue City
Shares Violent and Singleplayer; rated 0.5 lower; released within 1 year.
- Year
- 2023
- Rating
- ★ 3.9
- Playtime
- 5h
- Finish rate
- 78%
- Shared genres
- 3, 4
-
58%
7. A Plague Tale: Requiem
Shares Cinematic, Exploration, Third Person and Singleplayer; released within 2 years.
- Year
- 2022
- Rating
- ★ 4.3
- Playtime
- 5h
- Finish rate
- 86%
- Shared genres
- 3, 4
-
58%
8. Lost Judgment
Shares Cinematic, Third Person and Singleplayer; about 11h longer.
- Year
- 2021
- Rating
- ★ 4.3
- Playtime
- 12h
- Finish rate
- 83%
- Shared genres
- 3, 4
-
58%
9. Star Wars Jedi: Fallen Order
Shares Exploration and Third Person; rated 0.3 lower; about 7h longer.
- Year
- 2019
- Rating
- ★ 4.1
- Metacritic
- 80
- Playtime
- 8h
- Finish rate
- 83%
- Shared genres
- 3, 4
-
58%
10. Still Wakes the Deep
Shares Singleplayer; rated 0.6 lower; about 5h longer; same release year.
- Year
- 2024
- Rating
- ★ 3.9
- Playtime
- 6h
- Finish rate
- 85%
- Shared genres
- 3, 4
-
58%
11. The Dark Pictures Anthology: House of Ashes
Shares Multiple Endings, Survival Horror and Third Person; rated 0.6 lower; about 5h longer.
- Year
- 2021
- Rating
- ★ 3.9
- Metacritic
- 73
- Playtime
- 6h
- Finish rate
- 93%
- Shared genres
- 3, 4
-
57%
12. The Dark Pictures Anthology: Little Hope
Shares Psychological, Multiple Endings, Survival Horror, Violent and Singleplayer; rated 0.7 lower; about 5h longer.
- Year
- 2020
- Rating
- ★ 3.8
- Metacritic
- 70
- Playtime
- 6h
- Finish rate
- 93%
- Shared genres
- 3, 4
-
57%
13. Judgment (2019)
Shares Cinematic, Third Person and Singleplayer; about 8h longer.
- Year
- 2019
- Rating
- ★ 4.4
- Metacritic
- 82
- Playtime
- 9h
- Finish rate
- 79%
- Shared genres
- 3, 4
-
57%
14. Dead Island 2
Shares Survival Horror and Singleplayer; rated 0.8 lower; about 10h longer; released within 1 year.
- Year
- 2023
- Rating
- ★ 3.7
- Metacritic
- 75
- Playtime
- 11h
- Finish rate
- 69%
- Shared genres
- 3, 4
-
57%
15. Mafia: The Old Country New
Shares Cinematic, Third Person and Singleplayer; rated 0.7 lower; about 15h longer; released within 1 year.
- Year
- 2025
- Rating
- ★ 3.8
- Playtime
- 16h
- Finish rate
- 96%
- Shared genres
- 3, 4
-
57%
16. Tormented Souls
Shares Survival Horror, Exploration, Third Person and Singleplayer; rated 0.8 lower.
- Year
- 2021
- Rating
- ★ 3.7
- Metacritic
- 76
- Playtime
- 4h
- Finish rate
- 76%
- Shared genres
- 3, 4
-
56%
17. Last Stop
Shares Multiple Endings, Survival Horror, Violent, Exploration and Great Soundtrack and 1 more tags; rated 1.1 lower; about 5h longer.
- Year
- 2021
- Rating
- ★ 3.4
- Metacritic
- 68
- Playtime
- 6h
- Finish rate
- 80%
- Shared genres
- 3, 4
-
56%
18. Jusant
Shares Cinematic, Exploration, Third Person and Singleplayer; rated 0.5 lower; released within 1 year.
- Year
- 2023
- Rating
- ★ 4.0
- Playtime
- 2h
- Finish rate
- 79%
- Shared genres
- 3, 4
-
56%
19. A Plague Tale: Innocence
Shares Violent, Third Person and Singleplayer; rated 0.3 lower; about 6h longer.
- Year
- 2019
- Rating
- ★ 4.1
- Metacritic
- 82
- Playtime
- 7h
- Finish rate
- 86%
- Shared genres
- 3, 4
-
55%
20. Silent Hill Homecoming
Shares Survival Horror, Third Person, Great Soundtrack and Singleplayer; rated 1.2 lower.
- Year
- 2008
- Rating
- ★ 3.2
- Metacritic
- 64
- Playtime
- 1h
- Finish rate
- 67%
- Shared genres
- 3, 4
If you're here, you'll probably want these too
Other ways people search for this
They all land here or on the matching platform / free / co-op tab — one ranked answer, not ten thin pages.
Questions people ask
What is the best game like Silent Hill 2 on Xbox?
On our similarity model, The Callisto Protocol is the closest match to Silent Hill 2 on Xbox — shares Cinematic, Survival Horror, Violent, Third Person and Singleplayer; rated 0.9 lower; about 6h longer; released within 2 years.
Which game like Silent Hill 2 is rated highest?
Judgment (2019) holds the highest player rating in this list at 4.4/5 from 63 players.
Is there a new game like Silent Hill 2 in 2026?
Mafia: The Old Country is the most recent match, released August 2025.
How this list is built
Every game in our catalog is scored against Silent Hill 2 on five signals: weighted tag overlap (rare tags count more), genre overlap, platform family overlap, rating and playtime proximity, and release era. The list is recomputed nightly as ratings and new releases change.
Base game data via RAWG.