Games like Return to Mysterious Island
Closest overall match: Lume (★ 3.0). Highest rated: The Longest Journey at ★ 4.3. Quickest to finish: Lume at about 1 hours.
We compared Return to Mysterious Island against every game in our catalog on shared tags, genre, rating, playtime and release era, and these 7 came closest. What ties them together most: Point & Click, Singleplayer and Female Protagonist.
-
66%
1. Lume
Shares Point & Click, Female Protagonist and Singleplayer; rated 0.8 lower.
- Year
- 2011
- Rating
- ★ 3.0
- Metacritic
- 69
- Playtime
- 1h
- Finish rate
- 61%
- Shared genres
- 3, 7, Casual
-
61%
2. Gray Matter
Shares Point & Click, Female Protagonist and Singleplayer.
- Year
- 2011
- Rating
- ★ 3.6
- Metacritic
- 72
- Playtime
- 3h
- Finish rate
- 90%
- Shared genres
- 3, Casual
-
60%
3. Bone: The Great Cow Race
Shares Point & Click and Singleplayer; rated 1.5 lower.
- Year
- 2008
- Rating
- ★ 2.3
- Metacritic
- 76
- Playtime
- 1h
- Shared genres
- 3
-
60%
4. Bone: Out From Boneville
Shares Point & Click and Singleplayer; rated 1.6 lower.
- Year
- 2008
- Rating
- ★ 2.2
- Metacritic
- 68
- Playtime
- 1h
- Shared genres
- 3
-
59%
5. The Longest Journey
Shares Point & Click, Female Protagonist and Singleplayer; rated 0.5 higher.
- Year
- 1999
- Rating
- ★ 4.3
- Metacritic
- 91
- Playtime
- 1h
- Finish rate
- 81%
- Shared genres
- 3, 7
-
59%
6. Secret Files: Tunguska
Shares Point & Click, Female Protagonist and Singleplayer; released within 2 years.
- Year
- 2006
- Rating
- ★ 3.6
- Metacritic
- 68
- Playtime
- 4h
- Finish rate
- 83%
- Shared genres
- 3
-
58%
7. Journey to the Center of the Earth
Shares Point & Click and Singleplayer; rated 2.0 lower; released within 1 year.
- Year
- 2003
- Rating
- ★ 1.9
- Metacritic
- 65
- Playtime
- 4h
- Finish rate
- 50%
- Shared genres
- 3, 7
If you're here, you'll probably want these too
Questions people ask
What is the best game like Return to Mysterious Island?
On our similarity model, Lume is the closest match to Return to Mysterious Island — shares Point & Click, Female Protagonist and Singleplayer; rated 0.8 lower.
Which game like Return to Mysterious Island is rated highest?
The Longest Journey holds the highest player rating in this list at 4.3/5 from 221 players.
How this list is built
Every game in our catalog is scored against Return to Mysterious Island on five signals: weighted tag overlap (rare tags count more), genre overlap, platform family overlap, rating and playtime proximity, and release era. The list is recomputed nightly as ratings and new releases change.
Base game data via RAWG.